Philosophy In Action

Every Sunday morning, philosopher Dr. Diana Hsieh answers your questions on the principles for living a happy, virtuous, and free life in her live Philosophy In Action Webcast. It's at 8 am PT / 9 am MT / 10 am CT / 11 am ET at http://www.PhilosophyInAction.com. Submit your questions here!
Managers
I would like to...
by comments
by date
by popularity
Sort
Display all
or
Enable filter
Status:Date:
  • Under consideration
  • In process
  • Scheduled
  • Rejected
  • Completed
  • Today
  • Last week
  • Last month
  • All
Apply

1 vote Vote

How should deadly diseases be kept out of a free society?

A free society is supposed to have open borders, yet wouldn't that make preventing the entry of foreign diseases impossible? A society that opens it borders inevitably puts itself at risk for foreign diseases simply because people aren't being...
Drew, 20.10.2014, 17:35
0 comments
0 votes Vote

Are some opinions more valid than others?

Many people, including my boyfriend, have told me that everyone has an opinion, and nobody is ever "right" or "wrong" in their opinion on something. But is that accurate? I often tell those people that opinions are personal evaluations of things...
Zak Szalewski, 20.10.2014, 08:06
0 comments
4 votes Vote

How can I motivate myself to act to further my goals despite my overwhelming lethargy?

I struggle with motivating myself to do what I know I should. I'm not inclined to do wrong, but I just find it hard to act to further my goals in life. I'm 26 and I live with my dad while I (slowly) finish my degree. I want to become financially...
Jackethan, 16.10.2014, 10:34
0 comments
2 votes Vote

Is it morally wrong for an atheist to work for a business that is affiliated with a church?

For many years I had a job teaching at a private preschool that is a part of a Methodist church, and I really loved my job. Every now and then I would get the feeling that I did not really belong among my coworkers since most of them were devout...
Kristin Power, 15.10.2014, 15:43
0 comments
6 votes Vote

Does the patent system need to be reformed?

Patents were meant to spur innovation and reward inventors financially. However, the system seems to have many flaws, such as: (1) Many patents are awarded to obvious "inventions" (such as one-click shopping) or whole problems (not just particular...
Alok, 12.10.2014, 07:09
1 comment
1 vote Vote

How can I learn to trust people again after years of behind-the-back betrayals?

I have been dealing with a problem that seems unsolvable. I met a Muslim man who blatantly lied to me about being married. Somehow this man has pitted my family, friends, employers, and strangers against me. I did nothing to this man. This has...
Lynn Lesth, 11.10.2014, 15:03
1 comment
2 votes Vote

Does the "political spectrum" have any validity?

Typically, when I admit my capitalist views people think of and call me a "far right-wing'er." This bothered me for quite some time because I am an openly bisexual man and the right is so closely associated with theocracy and anti-gay views....
Chris , 10.10.2014, 03:30
0 comments
0 votes Vote

Is there a reason why the villains of "Atlas Shrugged" don't want to live?

Toward the end of Ayn Rand's novel "Atlas Shrugged," Hank Rearden and Dagny Taggart realize that the looters do not want to live. Does it make sense to ask why that is -- meaning, why don't they want to live? In other words, is the question so...
Adam Jensen, 09.10.2014, 13:23
0 comments
7 votes Vote

Do prisoners have a right to religious freedom?

I recently saw an article about a prisoner suing for the right to worship the Flying Spaghetti Monster, as well as another about an upcoming Supreme Court case for a Muslim who would like to grow his beard longer than rules allow. My question is,...
Drew Fridley, 05.10.2014, 13:27
1 comment
2 votes Vote

Does ethics require impartiality?

Critics of egoism, particularly utilitarians, accuse egoists of being biased in favor of oneself without justification. They assert that a scientific ethics must be neutral and impartial: it must take a third-person viewpoint where the self isn't...
Adam, 04.10.2014, 09:41
0 comments
0 votes Vote

Is the pleasure/pain mechanism the basis of ethical norms?

Libertarian commentator Stefan Molyneux recently criticized Ayn Rand's ethics, particularly her solution to the "is-ought gap." He claims that her ethics relies on the pleasure-pain mechanism as the basis of ethics. So irrationality is penalized...
AlfredStappenbeck, 27.09.2014, 06:08
1 comment
1 vote Vote

Does virtue require actually performing virtuous acts?

In his essay, "Existentialism and Humanism," Jean-Paul Sartre argues that who you are is defined by what you do. One consequence of this is that you cannot hide behind claims about your moral character e.g. you cannot say "I am a just person"...
Adam , 25.09.2014, 01:34
0 comments
0 votes Vote

Does justice require proportionality?

The maxim that "the punishment should fit the crime" tends to go unquestioned in discussions of retributive justice. Those discussions often revolve around whether a particular punishment is proportional or not, rather than taking a step back and...
Adam, 25.09.2014, 01:25
0 comments
7 votes Vote

Do verbal insults sometimes justify a response of physical violence?

In a recent discussion of bullying, most people agreed that the child in question should not have hit the kids bullying him, given that those bullies were merely making awful remarks, as opposed to being violent or threatening. However, one...
Trey, 21.09.2014, 10:50
0 comments
0 votes Vote

Do I have a moral obligation to stay at my current company?

I am actively looking for a new job at a new company, but my current company has a position that would fit my skills and goals. For various reasons, I would prefer to work for a new company. If I got a new job at my current company, would I be...
Smedley Whiplash, 21.09.2014, 08:04
0 comments
1 vote Vote

Can crowdsourcing raise money for an academic paleontology project?

I would like to begin a project that would require some funding, and I have been considering crowdsourcing, similar to your recent efforts on the anti-personhood campaign. My project is a systematic study of fossils found in various counties in...
James, 19.09.2014, 08:54
0 comments
3 votes Vote

Should spanking be banned as child abuse?

Studies have shown that spanking is harmful and ineffective, and yet spanking remains a common parenting discipline approach. (Some public schools use it, even against the express wishes of the parents.) Does spanking violate a child's rights? If...
Jenn Casey , 18.09.2014, 08:02
0 comments
2 votes Vote

Is it wrong to conceal information from my father while I live in his home?

I am a 21 year old gay college student still living with my parents as I pay my own tuition and progress through college. Both of my parents know I'm gay. My mom is completely fine with it; it's a sore subject with my dad and it's something we...
Zak, 14.09.2014, 16:05
0 comments
1 vote Vote

Is the distinction between needs and wants valid?

Anti-capitalist philosophers such as Giles Deleuze accuse the capitalist system of depending on blurring the distinction between needs and wants and tyrannizing over us by implanting artificial needs into our minds. In contrast, George Reisman...
Adam , 13.09.2014, 16:04
0 comments
1 vote Vote

What is moral character?

In "Ayn Rand's Normative Ethics," Tara Smith describes moral character as an aspect of human action, as a sort of averaging of the type of actions someone performs. In contrast, most Aristoteleans regard moral character as an aspect of the person...
Adam, 12.09.2014, 02:38
0 comments
2 votes Vote

Is random jury selection necessary to ensure defendants receive a fair trial?

In your 15 May 2011 podcast, you discussed whether or not it is moral to compel people to serve on juries. I agree with your conclusion that it is not moral, and that jury duty should instead be voluntary. But you went on to suggest that...
sirchess, 11.09.2014, 14:29
0 comments
2 votes Vote

Can morality be studied via scientific studies?

In other words, is it possible to conduct research into morality, especially larger field studies, thereby bolstering the case for ethical egoism? I've seen several such studies that examine moral behavior and what it might mean. For example, I...
Tili Jubilee, 11.09.2014, 14:26
1 comment
1 vote Vote

Should a person study mindsets before philosophy?

In a prior radio show, you said that adopting a rational philosophy like Objectivism is not a guarantee of rationality and other virtues in practice, but appears more to be a kind of "moral amplifier." If I remember correctly, you said that...
legendre007, 31.08.2014, 11:56
0 comments
9 votes Vote

Was the Civil War fought for just reasons?

Typically, we hear that the American Civil War was fought to free the slaves in the South. A competing narrative is that the South was fighting for state's rights. It would seem to me that neither of these are strictly true, the North was...
Thomas Marshall, 26.08.2014, 07:57
0 comments
16 votes Vote

What's right or wrong in Michael Huemer's critique of "The Objectivist Ethics"?

I found Professor Michael Huemer's essay "Critique of 'The Objectivist Ethics'" to be a very thoughtful and persuasive essay. It convinced me that Ayn Rand's ethics has a number of logical and possibly empirical flaws in it. Do you find any of...
Joshua Brownstein, 17.08.2014, 19:36
1 comment
3 votes Vote

Is voting for the welfare statist policies and politicians an initiation of force?

I come across right-wing people who proclaim to me that the State is justified to use physical force to deport undocumented Latino immigrants. They tell me this is justified because Latinos consistently vote in favor of politicians who expand the...
legendre007, 12.08.2014, 21:00
0 comments
15 votes Vote

Should scientists value philosophy?

Recently, when an interviewer asked the famous astrophysicist and science popularizer Neil deGrasse Tyson about his opinion on philosophy, Tyson replied that he has low regard for the entire discipline of philosophy. Tyson said that the problem...
legendre007, 12.08.2014, 05:33
0 comments
2 votes Vote

Should medical debt be treated like any other debt in a person's FICA score?

Recently, credit scoring company FICO announced that it wouldn't treat medical debt the same as other debts. Most unpaid debts are medical debts. A FICO representative explained the change as follows: “What research has shown us is medical...
Josh Yokela, 10.08.2014, 21:28
1 comment
7 votes Vote

Are sports fans collectivists?

A friend of mine thinks that sports fans are living vicariously through the players and are thus collectivistic. I think this is an overgeneralization from contact with super-fans of pro sports. Getting mad when "my" team loses and saying things...
Josh, 04.08.2014, 14:00
0 comments
7 votes Vote

Are manners objective?

In a recent Rapid Fire Question, I think you rather too quickly dismissed the idea that manners or etiquette can be objective. You fairly quickly threw the whole lot of them over into the socially-subjective category. However, I think there's a...
Robert Garmong, 02.08.2014, 11:03
0 comments

Pages< 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ...9 >