Philosophy In Action All the ideas and discussions
46 votes Vote

Once some children are genetically engineered, wouldn't discrimination against natural children be inevitable?

Assume that humanity has advanced to the technological capacities of the movie "Gattaca," where the best possible genes for each child could be (and mostly would be) chosen before implantation of the embryo. In that case, how could society prevent discrimination against people who were conceived naturally, such that their genes were just a random assortment of better and worse? Those chosen genes would include genes for determination, the desire to learn, motivation, on so on, so engineered people would always win out based on merit. The movie "Gattaca" shows a natural child rising above his engineered counterparts because of his great determination and spirit. The movie's tagline is even "there is no gene for the human spirit." But if there is such a thing as a human spirit, then there surely must be a gene for it. So would discrimination against natural children be inevitable? If so, would it be unjust?

Anonymous , 23.07.2013, 10:24
Idea status: completed


Tjitze Boer, 21.08.2013, 04:07
I'd be a lot more scared for discrimination of those who have been by those who aren't.

Leave a comment