Philosophy In Action All the ideas and discussions
11 votes Vote

Why are disputes so belligerent in online communities?

I've noticed that people get into very loud and heated disputes online, whereas that doesn't seem to happen in local communities. Disputes in local communities tend to be less frequent, less belligerent, and last for a shorter time -- even when some people end up hating each other and refusing to have anything to do with each other in the end. Why is that? Also, why do people who are closest with each other (whether close friends, dating, or married) seem to agree more on hot-button issues? Are people are more willing to reject a stranger's arguments than those of a friend? Is that an error?

Brian , 25.01.2012, 20:15
Idea status: completed

Comments

Paul Hsieh, 26.01.2012, 11:28
That's almost like the old joke:
"Why are disputes in academia so bitter?"
"Because the stakes are so small."
Brian, 26.01.2012, 11:32
That doesn't look anything like my original submission, except for the last couple questions, so I'm not sure why my name is attributed to it. I do still agree with the sentiment of the statement, though.
DianaHsieh, 26.01.2012, 17:39
Hi Brian -- I edit questions before posting them... and in this case, I wanted to add a bit of context for your questions. Thanks again for submitting it!

Leave a comment