Philosophy In Action All the ideas and discussions
4 votes Vote

Should rational people volunteer for the military?

How do you reconcile the concept of the inalienable rights to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness with volunteering for the military, a profession that requires obeying the orders of others -- especially when those orders may very well get you killed? If you still had the right to pursue your happiness, you could decline an unpleasant or dangerous order since inalienable implies you still retained your rights -- even after consenting to serve. But that's not how the military works -- or could work.

Robert Schecter , 31.05.2011, 20:01
Idea status: completed

Comments

Jennifer Snow, 04.06.2011, 18:18
A key to figuring the answer out: pursuit of happiness is a long-term, in-context thing. It doesn't necessarily mean doing exactly whatever you feel like doing at any given moment. (That would be whim-worship.) A person who thinks long-term may indeed find that accepting the legal authority of military leadership and obeying even extremely dangerous orders is precisely what *enables* them to live the life they want to live and thus to pursue the type of happiness that they have decided they want.

Leave a comment